Public Perceptions of Pine Barrens Restoration on the Chequamegon Nicolet National Forest
Northern Research Station social scientists and university partners have been collaborating with managers on the Lakewood-Laona Ranger District in Wisconsin since 2014 to support forest management and restoration activities in the globally rare pine barrens community that occurs there. They focus on understanding public opinions about the Forest Service, local staff, landscape preferences, and management actions to help Forest staff communicate with residents and visitors as well as manage forests with users in mind.

Researchers and forest staff observe recent pine barrens restoration activities on the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest.
In Wisconsin, communities near the pine barrens landscapes in the Lakewood-Laona District on the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest are at risk from large fires (greater than 1,000 acres) because of a history of fire suppression, decreased precipitation, and high vegetation density. Departures from historical landscape conditions have also altered wildlife species composition and diversity. Forest managers are interested in understanding how nearby residents and visitors feel about various forest management activities undertaken to decrease wildfire risk and restore historical plant and wildlife species.
Social scientists have partnered with managers since 2014 to understand landowners’ and visitors’ attitudes and opinions about forest management goals, vegetation treatments, and specific project outcomes, along with their level of trust in U.S. Forest Service staff and preferences for different pine barrens landscapes. This research quantifies and demonstrates the level of public trust in Forest Service staff to make management decisions, clarifies benefits and challenges of forest restoration, and captures landowners’ reactions and resilience to landscape changes over time. These insights can make it easier for Forest Service staff to manage and restore local pine barrens landscapes while considering the community’s concerns and preferences.
Key Findings
- While many landowners were uncertain about long-term outcomes related to restoration activities, over 60 percent agreed that actions like prescribed fire and logging were acceptable to achieve goals, and more than 60 percent agreed that they trusted local staff to make decisions related to prescribed fire, timber management, and oversight of logging activities.
- Forest managers identified invasive species, climate change, and economic concerns as current and future challenges to achieving management goals. The social issues, including fire acceptance, fire risk, and aesthetics, were predominant challenges as were concerns about budgets for restoration programs and fire.
- When shown different visualizations of pine barren restoration options, residents and visitors preferred images depicting smaller canopy openings and higher tree densities, although several images with open characteristics were also favored. Management implications include using design strategies such as leaving a few mature trees in foreground views (e.g., along roads or trails) and introducing a variety of heights in vegetation to add visual interest to the landscape.
- A derecho (inland hurricane) in 2019 caused changes in landscape character and property destruction leading residents to experience solastalgia, the distress associated with losing a place that once provided solace. Landowners differed in how they planned to move forward, with some cleaning up their properties and others letting their properties return to a more “natural” state.

A forest at the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest prior to restoration.
Pine barrens, which are open, fire-dependent ecological communities, do not conform to the Northwoods aesthetic favored by many people who live near and visit the Lakewood-Laona District. Learning about how pine barrens were perceived by residents and visitors was an important goal of this research.
Data collection with local landowners and visitors in the area began in 2016 with an initial four-wave mail survey and on-site visitor surveys. This initial research established baseline information regarding residents’ and visitors’ perceptions of restoration and trust of local Forest Service staff to make relevant decisions.
In a second phase of the research in 2019, scientists sought to understand what forest management experts saw as the key benefits, challenges, and characteristics of pine barrens ecosystems. Managers and other experts were consulted through a three round process to develop consensus around these issues. Importantly, a set of agreed upon characteristics of pine barrens were developed and used to support communications and further research with the public.

Aftermath of a prescribed burn in the Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest as part of an effort to restore pine barrens ecosystems.
Results from the expert study were used to develop representations of landscapes (visualizations) that were ranked by landowners according to their preferences. A range of attributes were studied in visualizations: fire intervals necessary to maintain the condition, levels of overstory tree density, shrub density, standing dead trees, and location of trees in fore, mid, and background.
A derecho, or inland hurricane, occurred in the summer of 2019 and significantly affected landowners’ property near the pine barrens restoration area. The storm provided scientists the opportunity to investigate how the owners experienced landscape changes and how they planned to move forward managing their land in the storm’s wake. Landowners had a strong sense of place for the Northwoods through which they experienced multiple drivers of change and loss.
Researchers continue to partner with the Lakewood-Laona District staff to track resident and visitor opinions about the Forest Service, pine barrens restoration, and economic and non-economic benefits over time.
Outcomes
This research has quantified public attitudes about the Forest Service and local restoration work over time and conveyed people’s preferences and concerns to the Lakewood-Laona District managers, who take them into account when managing the pine barrens landscape.
People
-
Person
Kristin Floress, PhD
Research Social Scientisthttps://research.fs.usda.gov/about/people/kristin.m.floress -
Person
Paul H. H. Gobster, PhD
Senior Research Landscape Architect, Emeritushttps://research.fs.usda.gov/about/people/paul.gobster -
Chequamegon Nicolet National Forest
John Lampereur
District Silviculturist -
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Adena Rissman
Professor -
Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources
Bob Smail
Research Scientist -
University of Minnesota
Ingrid Schneider
Professor -
University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point
Anna Haines
Professor Emerita