Planting diversity and density shape native plant survival and community assembly in tropical forest restoration

Three-year old restoration plantings of native woody and fern species in an old pasture previously planted with native Acacia koa trees in Hakalau Forest National Wildlife Refuge.
In Hawaii, planting old pastures with the native tree Acacia koa is a common forest restoration strategy. The goal is to support natural secondary succession to a more diverse forest, but invasive grasses still remain dominant in the understory. Native species aren't recruiting naturally in these areas, so managers are looking at ways to underplant koa monocultures with more diverse species, often using a plantation approach with widely spaced plants.
While understory plantings of subtrees and shrubs are often successful from a survival standpoint, they rarely decrease invasive grass biomass or lead to newly recruiting native species. To explore new restoration strategies, researchers used a forest node approach, where smaller, dense pockets of native species were planted together. For the study, they explored how diversity and planting density impacted survival, growth, and invasive grass cover.
Plots were created with different densities of species at two different densities of plants per plot. Three years after planting, the four-species combination resulted in the highest survival, likely due to the species assemblies in that design. Greatest native species cover occurred in the four- and eight-species high density plantings, showing that planting at high density didn't increase outplant mortality. Within this timeframe, researchers didn't see differences in invasive grass cover between treatments, probably due to the short time frame of the study.
The researchers plan to continue monitoring these plots to follow invasive grass biomass and cover, native plant growth and cover, and monitor for native plant recruitment. In the meantime, the results show that high-density plantings may accelerate tree canopy development in wet forests dominated by invasive grasses, offering a pathway to reestablish forest structure in degraded pasturelands. The findings suggest that higher diversity plantings may offer a bet-hedging strategy for managers in the event that some species fail to establish.