Variation in Avian Predation Pressure as a Driver for the Diversification of Periodical Cicada Broods

Abstract

Periodical cicadas live 13 or 17 years underground as nymphs, then emerge in synchrony as adults to reproduce. Developmentally synchronized populations called broods rarely coexist, with one dominant brood locally excluding those that emerge in off years. Twelvemodern 17-year cicada broods are believed to have descended from only three ancestral broods following the last glaciation. Themechanisms by which these daughter broods overcame exclusion by the ancestral brood to synchronously emerge in a different year, however, are elusive. Here, we demonstrate that temporal variation in the population density of generalist predators can allow intermittent opportunities for new broods to invade, even though a single brood remains dominant most of the time. We show that this mechanism is consistent, in terms of the type and frequency of brood replacements,with the distribution of periodical cicada broods throughout North America today. Although we investigate one particularly charismatic case study, the mechanisms involved (competitive exclusion, Allee effects, trait variation, predation, and temporal variability) are ubiquitous and could contribute to patterns of species diversity in a range of systems.

Citation

Huffmyer, William L.; Ji, Fang; Blackwood, Julie C.; Hastings, Alan; Koenig, Walter D.; Liebhold, Andrew M.; Machta, Jonathan; Abbott, Karen C. 2024. Variation in Avian Predation Pressure as a Driver for the Diversification of Periodical Cicada Broods. The American Naturalist. 203(3): E92-E106. https://doi.org/10.1086/728118.