Fort Valley Experimental Forest

The first Forest Service research facility established in the Nation, the Fort Valley Experimental Forest (formerly the Coconino Experiment Station) opened in August 1908. The site was established after two lumbermen, the Riordan brothers, from Flagstaff, Arizona, asked Gifford Pinchot (the first Chief of the Forest Service) to determine why the area's ponderosa pine forest was not regenerating after logging.
Fort Valley became a major field and laboratory site for forest management investigations. Because it was the initial Forest Service research facility, the list of scientists who visited or worked there reads like a "Who's Who" of early forest researchers: Emanuel Fritz, T.S. Woolsey, Jr., Enoch W. Nelson, Edward C. Crafts, Hermann Krauch, Bert Lexen, Charles Cooperrider, Clarence F. Korstian, and E.M. Hornibrook, among many others.
Fort Valley's first responsibility was mensurational studies. Researchers studied natural and artificial regeneration, stand improvement, sample plots, and climate — everything that might influence a tree throughout its life.
Check out the Fort Valley Experimental Forest Brochure for more information.
Background Information and History
In December 1907, Forest Service Chief Gifford Pinchot requested that Raphael Zon, Chief of the Division of Silvics, develop plans for permanent experiment stations devoted to scientific research on the national forests. The next year Zon traveled to Arizona after Frank C.W. Pooler, the Forest Supervisor of the Coconino National Forest, suggested his forest as an ideal site for the first research location. Gustaf A. Pearson, Raphael Zon, and Willard Drake explored land on the Coconino, eventually selecting the area of Fort Valley, an isolated area near Flagstaff, as the most suitable site.
Early research examined ponderosa pine forest management practices, as well as the effects of weather on seed regeneration. Pearson and Region 3 silviculturist T.S. Woolsey, Jr. established permanent sample plots over all the various forest types in the southwest in 1912. They measured, photographed, and inventoried the plots every five years until Pearson's retirement in 1944. NAU forestry professors and students have been remeasuring the plots for the past eight years, providing a ninety-year record of change.
A weather study initiated in 1916 followed biologist C. Hart Merriam study in 1889 when he suggested the life zones theory based on his work on the San Francisco Peaks. Fort Valley scientists placed weather recording instruments and nurseries at various altitudes. They planted exotic species to see if they would survive and take weather readings weekly.
By 1927, Fort Valley's scope of operations had grown to include Range studies. Charles K. Cooperrider was the head of this Division. Scientists studied domestic and wildlife grazing damage to tree reproduction and also studied range grasses. Permanent Range Study Plots were established around Region 3 and are still being monitored.
Civilian Conservation Corps workers helped expand the site's building, facilities, and permanent structures during the 1930s. During World War II, Fort Valley staff gave radio interviews promoting the importance of forest research on national resources in wartime.
During the 1950s, budget cuts and agency reorganization led to the decline in use of the Fort Valley site. The facilities were used intermittently over the subsequent years by outside groups, but more recent work by the USFS and Northern Arizona University have seen the site gain new importance. The Fort Valley campus is now listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Keith Moser and others recently conducted an interview with Melissa Sevigny, a reporter with KNAU Arizona Public Radio. This 4-minute interview covers a brief history of the Fort Valley Experimental Forest.
KNAU Radio Interview (Download or Listen): At Century-Old Experimental Forest, History is in the Trees
Ecology
Rainfall in Fort Valley is roughly 22 inches per year, with snowfall roughly 80 inches. Colder temperatures occur in January, with the coldest recorded at -37°F on January 12, 1963. The warmest temperature recorded was 98°F on July 5, 1985. The wettest date was August 24, 2006, receiving 4.0 inches of precipitation.
Research – Historical and Present
Researchers past and present at Fort Valley have studied natural and artificial regeneration, stand improvement, sample plots, climate—everything that might influence a tree throughout its life.
In 1910, Forest Service engineer Harold S. Betts led a research test of ponderosa pine's ability to produce resin. The initial response warranted more research the following year over a larger area. Results indicated that ponderosa pines produce resin at about 4/5 the quantity of southeastern trees even though factors such as length of season are the same. Resin quality is similar, and the main problem to developing turpentine operations in northern Arizona was the lack of skilled laborers at that time. The potential existed for a market, but the idea was never pursued.
In 1912, Pearson and the silviculturist for the Southwest Region of the Forest Service, T.S. Woolsey, Jr. established permanent sample plots over all the various forest types in the southwest. They measured, photographed, and inventoried the plots every five years until Pearson's retirement in 1944. Northern Arizona University forestry professors and students have been remeasuring the plots for the past eight years, providing a ninety-year record of change.
A weather study initiated in 1916 followed biologist C. Hart Merriam’s study in 1889, when he suggested the life zones theory based on his work on the San Francisco Peaks. Fort Valley scientists placed weather recording instruments and nurseries at various altitudes. They planted exotic species to see if they would survive and took weather readings weekly.
By 1927, Fort Valley's scope of operations had grown to include range studies. Charles K. Cooperrider headed this Division. Scientists studied domestic and wildlife grazing damage to tree reproduction, as well as studies on range grasses. Researchers established permanent range study plots around the Southwest Region, which are still monitored today.
Research Opportunities
The Experimental Forest & Range (EFR) Network encourages re-use of the data collected by its members. We also recognize the importance to our participating scientists of receiving proper credit for the contribution their data make to other projects. It is also important to both our scientists and to Forest Service Research & Development (R&D) that we understand who is using the EFR Network data. The scientists use this information in their performance reviews; Forest Service R&D uses it to guide decisions on allocation of resources (e.g., to web-based access to data, re-packaging of data products for particular audiences, etc.) and for its performance review with Congress. Therefore, most EFR Network research data are covered by a data use agreement. If you are familiar with the Long Term Ecological Research network, you will notice that this agreement has been modeled on their agreement.
Long-term Monitoring and Data
Fort Valley Experimental Forest 30-minute meteorological data from 2003 is available in a number of different ways:
- Precipitation and temperature data summarized every 30 minutes from 2003, provided by the Forest Service Research Data Archive.
- A variety of data summaries (average temperature, precipitation, snow by month), provided by the Western Regional Climate Center.
- SNOTEL (Snow Telemetry) provided by the Natural Resources Conservation Service.
Key Personnel
Scientist in Charge
-
Person
W. Keith Moser
Research Forester (Silviculturist) and Scientist-in-Charge, Fort Valley Experimental Foresthttps://research.fs.usda.gov/about/people/warren.k.moser
Treesearch Publications
- Anthony Caprio, Wayne Clatterbuck, Corli Coetsee, James D. Haywood, Sarah E. Hobbie, William A. Hoffmann, John Kush, Tom Lewis, W. Keith Moser, Steven T. Overby, William A. Patterson, Kabir G. Peay, Peter B. Reich, Casey Ryan, Mary Anne Sword Sayer, Bryant C. Scharenbroch, Tania Schoennagel, Gabriel Reuben Smith, Kirsten Stephan, Chris Swanston, Monica G. Turner, J. Morgan Varner, Robert B. Jackson, Adam F. A. Pellegrini, Tyler Refsland, Colin Averill, César Terrer, A. Carla Staver, Dale Brockway. 2021. Decadal changes in fire frequencies shift tree communities and functional traits
- Mathias Steckel, W. Keith Moser, Miren del Río, Hans Pretzsch. 2020. Implications of reduced stand density on tree growth and drought susceptibility: A study of three species under varying climate
- Thomas E. Kolb, Kelsey Flathers, John B. Bradford, Caitlin Andrews, Lance A. Asherin, W. Keith Moser. 2020. Stand density, drought and herbivory constrain ponderosa pine regeneration pulse
- Jianwei Zhang, William Oliver, Russ Graham, W. Keith. Moser. 2020. The Level-of-Growing-Stock (LOGS) study on thinning ponderosa pine forests in the US West: A long-term collaborative experiment in density management
- Damon Vaughan, David Auty, Thomas E. Kolb, Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Kurt H. Mackes, Joseph Dahlen, W. Keith Moser. 2019. Climate has a larger effect than stand basal area on wood density in Pinus ponderosa var. scopulorum in the southwestern USA
- Jose Iniguez, James F. Fowler, W. Keith Moser, Carolyn H. Sieg, Scott Baggett, Patrick Shin. 2019. Tree and opening spatial patterns vary by tree density in two old-growth remnant ponderosa pine forests in Northern Arizona, USA
- Kelsey N. Flathers, Thomas E. Kolb, John B. Bradford, Kristen M. Waring, W. Keith Moser. 2016. Long-term thinning alters ponderosa pine reproduction in northern Arizona
- Steven T. Overby, Suzanne M. Owen, Stephen C. Hart, Dan G. Neary, Nancy C. Johnson. 2015. Soil microbial community resilience with tree thinning in a 40-year-old experimental ponderosa pine forest
- Gerald J. Gottfried, Peter F. Ffolliott, Kenneth N. Brooks, Randy Kolka, Carol B. Raish, Dan G. Neary. 2014. Contributions of studies on experimental forests to hydrology and watershed management [Chapter 14]
- Brian W. Geils, Susan Olberding. 2012. Research on climate impacts to forests began early at Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- Jonathan D. Bakker, Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Peter Z. Fule, David W. Huffman, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. "Growing trees backwards": Description of a stand reconstruction model
- Susan Olberding. 2008. "It was a young man's life": G. A. Pearson
- Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. 93 Years of stand density and land-use legacy research at the Coulter Ranch Study Site
- Susan Olberding, Karen Malis-Clark, Peter J. Pilles, Dennis Lund. 2008. A century of cooperation: The Fort Valley Experimental Forest and the Coconino National Forest in Flagstaff (P-53)
- Daniel P. Huebner, Susan Olberding, Byron Peterson, Dino DeSimone. 2008. A century of meteorological observations at Fort Valley Experimental Forest: A cooperative observer program success story
- Joseph E. Crouse, Peter Z. Fule. 2008. A visual progression of the Fort Valley Restoration Project treatments using remotely sensed imagery (P-53)
- W. Walker Chancellor, David W. Huffman, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Characteristics of buckbrush shrubs exposed to herbivores after seven years of protection
- Gerald J. Gottfried, Peter F. Ffolliott, Daniel G. Neary. 2008. Contributions of silvicultural studies at Fort Valley to watershed management of Arizona's ponderosa pine forests
- David W. Huffman, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Dynamics of buckbrush populations under simulated forest restoration alternatives
- Benjamin P. De Blois, Alex. J. Finkral, Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Early thinning experiments established by the Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- Joy N. Mast, Stephen S. Sackett, Michael R. Wagner, Margaret M. Moore, W. Wallace Covington, Peter Z. Fule, Stephen C. Hart, Thomas E. Kolb. 2008. Ecological restoration experiments (1992-2007) at the G. A. Pearson Natural Area, Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- Michael T. Stoddard, Christopher M. McGlone, Peter Z. Fule. 2008. Effects of ecological restoration alternative treatments on nonnative plant species establishment
- Stephen S. Sackett, Sally M. Haase. 2008. Fire and fuels research at Fort Valley and Long Valley Experimental Forests
- Stephen S. Sackett, Sally M. Haase. 2008. Fire and fuels research at Fort Valley and Long Valley Experimental Forests (P-53)
- Daniel C. Laughlin, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Forest and range research on the "Wild Bill Plots" (1927-2007)
- Brian W. Geils. 2008. Forest pathology and entomology at Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- L. J. (Pat) Heidmann. 2008. Forest regeneration research at Fort Valley
- Jacob H. Dyer, Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Margaret M. Moore, Jonathan D. Bakker. 2008. Forest structure and tree recruitment changes on a permanent historical Cinder Hills plot over a 130-Year Period
- Susan Olberding, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Fort Valley Experimental Forest-A Century of Research 1908-2008
- Susan Olberding, Margaret M. Moore. 2008. Fort Valley Experimental Forest-A Century of Research 1908-2008 (P-53)
- Brian W. Geils. 2008. Fort Valley studies: A natural laboratory for research and education
- Andrew J. Sanchez Meador, Susan Olberding. 2008. Fort Valley's early scientists: A legacy of distinction
- John D. Bailey. 2008. Forty years later at Taylor Woods: Merging the old and new
- Peter F. Ffolliott, Gerald J. Gottfried, Cody L. Stropki, L. J. Heidmann. 2008. Growth of a 45-year-old ponderosa pine plantation: An Arizona case study
- Laura E. DeWald, Mary Mahalovich. 2008. Historical and contemporary lessons from ponderosa pine genetic studies at the Fort Valley Experimental Forest, Arizona
- Peter F. Ffolliott. 2008. Historical review of Fort Valley studies on stand management
- Peter F. Ffolliott. 2008. Historical review of Fort Valley studies on stand management (P-53)
- Frank Wadsworth. 2008. Memories of Fort Valley from 1938 to 1942
- G. Sam Foster. 2008. Opening remarks for the Fort Valley Centennial Celebration
- Katherine Elliott, James Vose, Alan S. White. 2008. Pine regeneration following wildland fire
- Scott R. Abella. 2008. Plant recruitment in a northern Arizona ponderosa pine forest: Testing seed- and leaf litter-limitation hypotheses
- Carlos Ochoa, Alexander Fernald, Vincent Tidwell. 2008. Rainfall, soil moisture, and runoff dynamics in New Mexico pinon-juniper woodland watersheds
- Henry A. Pearson, Warren P. Clary, Margaret M. Moore, Carolyn H. Sieg. 2008. Range management research, Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- Franco Biondi, Fares Qeadan. 2008. Removing the tree-ring width biological trend using expected basal area increment
- Joseph E. Crouse, Margaret M. Moore, Peter Fule. 2008. Revisiting Pearson's climate and forest type studies on the Fort Valley Experimental Forest
- Jeremy C. Young. 2008. Roots of research: Raphael Zon and the origins of forest experiment stations
- David R. Patton. 2008. The Fort Valley Experimental Forest, ponderosa pine, and wildlife habitat research
- Jonathan D. Bakker, Margaret M. Moore, Daniel C. Laughlin. 2008. The Hill plots: A rare long-term vegetation study
- Melissa J. Fischer, Kristen M. Waring, Richard W. Hofstetter, Thomas E. Kolb. 2008. The resin composition of ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) attacked by the roundheaded pine beetle (Dendroctonus adjunctus) (Coleoptera: Curculionidae, Scolytinae)
- Shirley Elston, Carolyn Shoemaker. 2008. The U.S. Geological Survey Paleomagnetics Laboratory at Fort Valley Experimental Forest-1970-1991
- Dan G. Neary, Sally M. Haase, Steven T. Overby. 2008. Total carbon and nitrogen in mineral soil after 26 years of prescribed fire: Long Valley and Fort Valley Experimental Forests
- Thomas E. Kolb, Nate G. McDowell. 2008. Tree ecophysiology research at Taylor Woods
- Becky K. Kerns, Margaret M. Moore, Stephen C. Hart. 2008. Understanding ponderosa pine forest-grassland vegetation dynamics at Fort Valley Experimental Forest using phytolith analysis
- Catherine Scudieri, James F. Fowler, Carolyn H. Sieg, Laura Williams, Sally M. Haase. 2008. Vascular plant checklist of the Chimney Spring and Limestone Flats Prescribed Burning Study Areas within ponderosa pine experimental forests in northern Arizona
- Malchus B. Baker, Peter F. Ffolliott. 1999. Chapter 5: Interdisciplinary land use along the Mogollon Rim
- Stephen S. Sackett, Sally M. Haase, Michael G. Harrington. 1994. Restoration of southwestern ponderosa pine ecosystems with fire
- Sally M. Haase. 1986. Effect of prescribed burning on soil moisture and germination of southwestern ponderosa pine seed on basaltic soils
- Gilbert H. Schubert. 1963. Methods of cutting ponderosa pine in the Southwest - Establishment report: Even-aged yield study, Plot 11
- Edward M. Gaines, Elmer W. Shaw. 1958. Half a century of research - Fort Valley Experimental Forest 1908-1958